Asymmetric shocks in Europe favour German Bunds - 2 November 2026
Third-quarter GDP figures illustrate the asymmetric impact of energy and fiscal shocks across Europe. German government bonds are emerging as clear winners.
Excluding Ireland¹, euro-area GDP grew by 0.3% in the third quarter, or 1.2% year-on-year. This is a solid result, but it masks marked divergences. Supported by a decisively expansionary fiscal policy, northern European economies have proved more resilient to the energy shock, with average year-on-year growth of 1.75%, the strongest since the post-Covid period. By contrast, France (-0.1%, bordering on recession) and, to a lesser extent, Italy (+0.8%) stand out as the weak links in the euro area, particularly vulnerable to rising energy prices and long-term interest rates (Chart 1).
_
¹ The extreme volatility of Irish GDP, which is heavily influenced by the behavior of multinational companies, makes it necessary to exclude Ireland from aggregate calculations.
In the short term, the recent acceleration in energy prices, combined with rising funding costs for the euro area’s most indebted sovereigns, particularly France, is likely to deepen these divergences further. With France and Italy together accounting for just over a third of euro-area GDP, the situation is becoming increasingly uncomfortable for the ECB.
Despite euro-area inflation of 4%, the ECB chose to hold off at its latest monetary policy meeting on 29 October. Encouragingly, it reports no evidence so far of second-round effects from the energy shock, particularly on wages. Meanwhile, German inflation appears increasingly well contained, partly thanks to a powerful fiscal shield. This is helping to limit both the scale and the pass-through of energy price increases. In October, inflation excluding food and energy fell back to 2.1% in Germany, its lowest level since the Covid-19 pandemic. Disinflation in services is also becoming more firmly established month by month (Chart 2).
Barring surprises, however, the continued rise in energy prices is likely to prompt the ECB to raise rates again in December, still as a preventive measure. Beyond that, uncertainty remains high, particularly given the situation in the Persian Gulf and the pressure on French and, to a lesser extent, Italian yields. Since late September, markets have begun to scale back their expectations for ECB rate rises in 2027, even as energy prices have accelerated. This unprecedented development reflects doubts about the strength of European growth and supports safe-haven assets, foremost among them German government bonds (Chart 3).
Despite the positive impetus from fiscal stimulus in northern European countries, the euro area’s economic and financial outlook therefore appears increasingly dependent on the external and domestic political environment. In the short term, markets will pay particular attention to the conflict in Iran, the US midterm elections on 3 November — which could influence US foreign policy — and the budget discussions in France.


